Episode 4 - Five nights of fury

HISTORICITY

Here we are! You’ve survived five nights of fury in Episode 4 of the Shackleton Series! Not only have you made it past halfway, but you’re taking it a step further to dig into the historicity of this part of the tale! Bravo! Let’s find out where this game sticks to the facts, and where it takes some minor detours.

In this episode we tried to give you brief glimpses into the realities of this comparatively short part of the journey. Truthfully, none of us at Escape Mail have ever endured anything quite like what these men went through, but we used our imaginations. Since frostbite wasn’t something we wanted to send you in an envelope, we landed on the Primus Stove; a singular source of heat (outside of one’s own body) that brought a flicker of hope in the coldest of days. Let’s begin!

Story pages and puzzle pages

In this episode, we deviated from the normal practice of telling events as they occurred. We tried to imagine how anyone could write anything during an icy, tumultuous, life-threatening, water-logged boat voyage. It just didn’t make sense. So we dated everything retrospectively. Our favourite fun fact (without a doubt!) is on page 34, where Holness falls through the ice into the water while in his sleeping bag. This moment reveals the incredible dangers of their escape as well as the vigil and courage of Shackleton to heave Holness out of the water. Other than the small graphic of the burnt match on page 38, these journal pages are 100% accurate to the best of our knowledge.

ENVELOPE (Exterior) 

The inspiration for the design of the exterior of the envelope comes from the danger of the crew’s escape through the ice. We wanted to depict the ocean and the chunks of ice that the boats would have had to navigate through, especially on the first day. These chunks were so big they could have easily crushed the ships had they closed back in around them. While the ice was very dangerous, it was also incredibly beautiful, which is why we went with the aquamarine tones. Lansing references Macklin who quoted Tennyson’s Morte d’Arthur: “...I never saw, nor shall see, here or elsewhere, till I die, not though I live three lives of mortal men, so great a miracle...”

Envelope (interior)

For six days and five nights, the crew’s world was incredibly small. It consisted of their 20-ish-foot lifeboat, and the other 8-10 men on board. We tried to imagine what else - besides the oars with which they rowed for dear life - was critical to them during this time.

Compass

There was perhaps no object as critical to their decision making as the compass. While Hudson was officially “navigator” it was Worsley whose brilliance shone in these days. Lansing describes how the men began to see him in a new light as he would continually take accurate sightings in horrible conditions. And when the Docker’s compass was smashed, Worsley's “little silver pocket compass” was all they had left to navigate by.

primus plate

As far as we know, there is no indication that a primus stove needed a plate to rest upon. However, for our puzzle, a plate with some precautionary words was quite helpful!

Sardine can

We chose to include a can of sardines primarily because it worked very well for this puzzle. We know from various accounts that by this time, all food brought for the voyage was fairly used up. The crew had anticipated crossing Antartica and consuming the food caches laid down by the Ross Sea Party on the other side of the continent. Would they have had a can of sardines? Plausible. But unlikely.

surgical Bandage

There were two surgeons on the expedition: Macklin and McIlroy. They were the ones that eventually amputated Blackboro’s frostbitten toes. Lansing describes them using “surgical gauze” and a few “surgical instruments” so we figured “surgical bandage” wasn’t a far cry from plausible.

matches

Matches were used to light the primus, smoke tobacco, and in some cases, provide the light necessary to read a compass. Lansing describes it plainly: “Macklin struck matches while Greenstreet tried to read the compass. But even under the shelter of the canvas, the wind snuffed out the matches almost as soon as they were lit. Macklin then took his knife and split the individual match heads to make them flare long enough so that Greenstreet could see the compass.” All this done in turbulent, sub-zero seas!

tobacco paper

Smoking tabacco was incredibly important to the men. Why is that? There may be a number of cultural (and perhaps chemical!) reasons, but there are also some pragmatic ones. Think about it: if you could never get warm, at least a cigarette emanates some heat. Furthermore, if you were always hungry, at least you had something in your mouth. Strikingly, after Holness fell in the ocean, he complained not about nearly dieing or about being ice-cold, but only about losing his precious tabacco.

Primus Stove

There were a few stoves brought on the expedition. These were critical implements for cooking various recipies, but most commonly, “hoosh” as it was referred to. According to CoolAntartica.com, “rather than being an actual recipe as such, hoosh is really just a word for a stew made from the limited ingredients you have at the time.” The cook, Green, did an excellent job feeding the crew with such limited supplies. When we dreamed up this series, we thought, “How cool would it be to make a stove?” and we almost gave up on the idea after it proved to be challenging. We’re glad we didn’t. Having done our fair share of back-country camping, this is one of the few items we actually are fairly familiar with in the real world. Hope you enjoyed its puzzle-ified re-creation!

seating chart grid

Shackleton was keenly aware of group dynamics and would by no means have left his crew’s arrangement up to Clark (the biologist). Furthermore, his crew had practiced the “escape from the ice” numerous times and “knew the drill” so to speak. The only adjustment that Lansing describes is when Shackleton lightens the load in the boats by disposing of some non-essential equiment. Otherwise, the boat teams did not change.

Wuzzle page

The back of the wuzzle page features an actual hand drawn map by Frank “Wuzzles” Worsley. We smudged most of it out so as to not distract from the puzzle content, but we love that it is both (a) real and (b) matches the font we created for Worsley (this map and others served as the template for the Wuzzles font we made).

Ice floe map

Unlike most of our maps, this one does not intend to be geographically accurate. In such a landscape, all these ice floes would have been in constant motion and flux. The crew’s path through the ice is also entirely fabricated. Another fabrication is the name “Endurance Glacier” which we needed for a puzzle, but in actual fact (1) didn’t exist in name at this time and (2) is now located near Elephant Island. However, there are a few factual elements that we did incorporate: (1) the aesthetic style matches that of the Episode 1 map which was based on a historical map (2) the marked distances to the various locations are approximately correct both in direction and in number (3) the ice begins more tightly packed and less so later in the maze (4) the path is circuitous and not direct, which was very much the case for this leg of their expedition.

boat photos

These photos are actual photos of the life boats. We took some creative liberties to add the necessary text to the boat labelled “JAMES CAIRD” in an effort to match the treatment and style of “STANCOMB WILLS” which is unaltered from the photo taken by Hurley.

additional photos

The rest of the photos in the journal pages are unaltered. They do not accurately depict different days (as is suggested by our notations on each photo). The artwork on page 41 (by Marston) does depict the voyage, but not a specific day as far as we know. Since no photos were taken during this time, these paintings survive as some of the most compelling depictions of the journey. They served to inspire and challenge us as we created this series (see any correlations between them and the ice floe map maze?) and we are incredibly grateful for Marston’s artistic abilities.

If you would like to make a comment on this Episode’s historicity, please reach out to us on social media or email us at info@theescapemail.com. Thank you!

BIBLIOGRAPHY

  • Cool Antarctica. “Antarctic Hoosh Recipe - What the Explorers Ate.” Accessed May 13, 2025. https://www.coolantarctica.com/schools/antarctic_hoosh_recipe.php.

  • Hurley, Frank, and George Marston. State Library - New South Wales. State Library of NSW, 1914-1917. State Library of NSW,https://www.sl.nsw.gov.au/. Accessed May 2024.

  • Lansing, Alfred. Endurance. Basic Books, 1959.

  • Shackleton, Ernest Henry. South. The Quarto Group, 2016.